An Open Letter to Ryan Murphy

By on Jul 11, 2012 in Inner Monologues | 3 comments

Share On GoogleShare On FacebookShare On Twitter

Dear Ryan Murphy,

First off, I love your work.  I loved Nip/Tuck, I was fascinated by the pilot for Pretty/Handsome, and I remain haunted by American Horror Story.  But my partner and I are of two minds when it comes to The Glee Project.  You see, we do like it—it’s an addictive show with formidable talent and fun challenges—but the concept confuses us.  Are you looking for talented youngsters who can sing, dance, and act?  Or are you looking for inspiration?

When The Glee Project premiered last summer, our impression was that you and the other producers of Glee would be searching amongst relative unknowns for fresh talent—people who can sing, dance, and act.  Once it premiered, however, it became clear that you were looking for inspirational stories amongst the contestants, hoping to write the contestant’s personal histories into the show.  (You’d say things like, “How do I write for you?”)  And that’s what happened with that season’s winners: Sam, a devout Christian, appears on Glee as Joe, a devout Christian; and Damian, an Irish immigrant, plays Rory, an Irish immigrant.  (And runner-up Alex, who oft dressed in drag, guest-starred in two episodes as a drag queen named Unique.)

However, most episodes are themed around acting challenges, with titles like “Vulnerability,” “Adaptability,” “Believability,” and even “Actability.”  But what’s the point of testing the contestants’ acting chops if the winners would just be playing themselves?

And for that matter, if you are looking for inspiration (which is fine, as long as that is your stated goal), why are you eliminating the most interesting of the contestants?

For example, let’s look at some of the contestants who have been eliminated so far this season: Dani, a lesbian; Tyler, a transgender man, and Mario, a blind man.  (And take note: I list these descriptors merely as attributes for these contenders and not their defining qualities—though they’d likely claim these attributes as “selling points” for b4eing cast on Glee.)  Three out of the five contestants eliminated so far are persons of color, as well.  Of the contestants that remain, only one (Abraham) isn’t Caucasian.  There is still some diversity:  Abraham is Asian, Ali is a paraplegic, Aylin is Muslim, Charlie has ADHD and low-spectral autism.  There might be even more diversity, but I don’t want to cast aspersions; I’m only stating the attributes of each contestant that they’ve already revealed.

Of the contestants who remain this summer, Blake, Lily Mae, Michael, and Nellie have no discernible source of diversity: from all appearances, they’re heterosexual, white, and middle-class or above.  Contestants whose stories would make Glee even more interesting and diverse are being voted off the musical-theater island.  (Not to reinforce quotas, but the show already has Asian characters and already has a paraplegic.)

Now, I understand the rationale behind many of the elimination decisions.  Those contestants made mistakes or were off their game that week.  But they are still works-in-progress.  At some point, the narrative potential of their histories has to be so alluring that they can be forgiven for their position on the learning curve.

As for the current season, what’s done is done; and I’m sure the winner will be a capable singer, dancer, and actor.  But next season, if you’re still looking to be inspired, I hope the winner is someone whose story is truly unique and who is working on the rest.

Dan Clarendon



  1. Linda

    September 17, 2012

    Post a Reply

    I am an internet-only subscriber, so I just started catching up on Glee Project this season…. I am sure there are thousands of others that would agree with you. I would love a response from Ryan Murphy… if he were truly inspired to write amazing stories, he should go looking for them. He is picking his story from a sea of people with the same dream…. if Mr. Murphy would like Glee to grow some roots instead of getting top heavy with wilting flowers he should go out and do some field work (or at least hire some people) on what exists in the teen world. What’s the story you want to tell Mr. Ryan Murphy? Instead of writing contrived characters and convoluted relationships, take this amazing premise of Glee and give your show some heart again.

    • Dan Clarendon

      September 23, 2012

      Post a Reply

      I totally agree, Linda. (And thanks for reading!) I’ll be curious to hear what you think of the end result of this season, so comment again when you’re caught up!

  2. Talya

    January 14, 2013

    Post a Reply

    I just read this post Dan & couldn’t agree more. As a theatre teacher, it makes me so angry that The Glee Project promotes the idea that good actors are just playing a version of themselves and then when the contestants get rejected (as happened to a former student of mine) it seems like he is rejecting their story/personality rather than just finding that they are not a good enough fit for the show that he is casting. Teenagers put themselves on the line every day just going to school, they shouldn’t be encouraged to do it on national television for our entertainment.

Leave a Reply